Infinite Scroll vs Pagination: How to Choose

Lists power so many products, feeds, search results, catalogs. Sooner or later you’ll face the classic decision: infinite scroll vs pagination, or the middle path, Load More. There isn’t one true answer. The right choice depends on user intent and what you want the screen to achieve. Let’s make the decision simple.

Start with intent, not UI

People use lists in two very different moods.

Exploration: feeds, galleries, inspiration

Curiosity rules here. Less friction means more discovery, and infinite scrolling keeps the momentum. It shines when your goal is exposure and time-on-experience, not precise refinding.

‍

Task completion: compare, refine, return

Find the right size. Compare specs. Jump back to that thing you saw. Here users need orientation, deep linking, and a clean way to return to spot. That’s where pagination UX excels. Load More can also work when you want speed and control on the same screen.

‍

Three patterns, three personalities

Infinite scroll

Perfect for discovery. It keeps momentum and reveals more content with less effort. If you choose it, make it resilient:

• Preserve scroll position when users open a detail and go back.
• Keep the page fast on average devices with virtualized lists/windowing.
• Ensure the footer and utilities are reachable (e.g., “Back to top” link, floating actions).
• For SEO, expose crawlable paths (e.g., indexable page-like URLs) and avoid hiding content behind client-only fetches.
  ‍

‍

Load more:

The middle path. A quick click adds a chunk, the layout remains stable, and users feel in control.

• Easy to show progress: “Showing 40 of 213”.
• Great when you want speed without sacrificing return-to-spot and deep linking.

‍

‍

Pagination:

Structure first. Best for search, ecommerce, admin tables, and documentation.

• Supports comparison and protects orientation.
• When you ship it, don’t starve pages. Slightly longer pages reduce thrash and still feel fast.

‍

‍

Build for access and speed

Good list UIs keep your place and work smoothly with keyboards and screen readers. Use clear landmarks, label pagination controls, and announce new results politely. Keep it fast by virtualizing long lists, lazy loading media, and recycling offscreen content. Most important, restore position when people go from detail to back.

‍

A simple way to decide

Ask five questions:

1. Is this screen about discovery or about completing a task?
   If it’s discovery, infinite scroll tends to win; if it’s task completion, start with pagination.
   
   
2. How important is “return to spot”?
   If users routinely compare items or revisit results, prefer pagination or a measured “Load More.”
   
   
3. Do people need to share or bookmark an exact spot?
   If yes, keep stable URLs. Pagination or Load More with URL parameters works best.
   
   
4. Do totals matter for trust or planning?
   If people care how many results there are, prefer pagination or Load More with a visible count.
   

Answer those, and the choice is rarely controversial.

‍

Measure what actually matters

When you ship, look beyond scroll depth. For exploratory feeds, track how often people save, share, or follow something new. For shopping and search, track how quickly they refine filters, how often they add to cart, and whether they can find an item again after a detour. Run a quick usability test that forces a return-and-refind moment. You’ll learn more from that than from any “time on page” metric.

‍

Final words

Trends come and go. Your users do not. Choose the pattern that fits their intent, keep performance and accessibility tight, and make sure search can follow along. If you are also unsure about best practices for adding navigation to your app, this post can help with your decision.